Three months after the China Quake
1BC Civ Forums
1BC Civ Forums
Home      Members   FAQ   Links
Welcome Guest ( Login | Register )
      


««12345»»»

Three months after the China QuakeExpand / Collapse
Author
Message
8/13/2008 10:22 PM


Grognard fantôme

Grognard fantôme

Last Seen:
Today @ 7:08 AM


Posts: 7,242
Visits: 9,608

jerm (8/13/2008)
What's wrong with Nationalism?

8/13/2008 11:02 PM


Day-Saver!

Day-Saver!

Last Seen:
Today @ 12:55 PM


Posts: 5,291
Visits: 27,180

Yeah, jerm. Nationalism is SO 18th-20th century. We're in the 21st now. Get with the program! Nuttin' wrong wit a little bit o' Patriotism, but Nationalism is just wrong, man, just wrong!
8/14/2008 12:47 AM


Elite Pathogen

Elite PathogenElite PathogenElite PathogenElite PathogenElite PathogenElite PathogenElite PathogenElite Pathogen

Last Seen:
Today @ 1:58 PM


Posts: 4,390
Visits: 10,911

[taunt]So Nationalism automatically leads to nuclear holocaust?  Hmm, not a very good argument there Scip.  I know you can do better .[/taunt]

Locus, what is the difference between Nationalism and Patriotism? 

8/14/2008 7:46 AM


Grognard fantôme

Grognard fantôme

Last Seen:
Today @ 7:08 AM


Posts: 7,242
Visits: 9,608

I think maybe you jokers are confusing love of Liberty, Democracy, Fraternity and a desire for it to be enjoyed by all humans as Patriotism [for the U.S.].

I love Canada. I love Australia. I love the U.K. I love France. I love Germany. Brazil, Belgium, India, Spain, Italy, Japan, etc.

I love them cause they are humane, just, prosperous nations that benefit their citizens and do not control individual lives primarily to benefit a  putatively "communist" ruling elite comprising tyrants and thugs. They are that way in large part because the U.S. helped to save them from tyrranny ~60 years ago.

In global Team Democracy, Team America is just the quarterback, not the sole player.

8/14/2008 8:47 AM


Day-Saver!

Day-Saver!

Last Seen:
Today @ 12:55 PM


Posts: 5,291
Visits: 27,180

Patriotism is questioning your government because you care about your country. Nationalism is blindly following your government come hell or high water because you are blinded by your patriotism.
8/14/2008 12:03 PM
Bismarcko' Magnifico

Bismarcko' Magnifico

Last Seen:
11/16/2008 2:20 PM


Posts: 1,056
Visits: 4,828

I disagree with that definition, LC.

Nationalism is pride in your own sovereignty and involves exclusive focus towards the betterment of your country even if it is irrespective of another country. The emphasis is still towards the betterment of one's own country and promotion of it's individual sovereignty. You're describing the extreme (aka sheeple) as if it's the default ignoring moderate Nationalists.

As far as patriotism is concerned, it's mainly symbolic and in the eye of the beholder for the most part...

...whether it's telling 7 year old kids the country isn't great or wearing flag pins

Sorry I couldn't stop myself on that last one.
8/14/2008 12:27 PM


Elite Pathogen

Elite PathogenElite PathogenElite PathogenElite PathogenElite PathogenElite PathogenElite PathogenElite Pathogen

Last Seen:
Today @ 1:58 PM


Posts: 4,390
Visits: 10,911

Yep, the most extreme forms of Nationalism are indeed a force for evil.  "My country Uber alis."  This is not the sole definition of Nationalism.  Patriotism, as far as I can tell (and there is a degree of subjectivity to both terms) is a mild form of Nationalism.  I believe a degree of nationalism is vital for a free nation's survival.  If one doesn't love his country, why would he fight for it?  Without some nationalism, we are all agents for our own goals, which is fine but there also needs to be a degree of working together as a nation towards common goals.  In short, bad nationalism is bad and good nationalism is... well good.  Ya know Locus, UNITY
8/14/2008 2:15 PM


Day-Saver!

Day-Saver!

Last Seen:
Today @ 12:55 PM


Posts: 5,291
Visits: 27,180

You take the bad with the good, jerm. Nationalism is an outdated concept, and one the world would be best leaving behind. That doesn't mean you get rid of all nations. But national integrity is different than nationalism. You mention, wars, and what people would fight for, if not, nationalism. Ok, wars are something we could do with out too, and I think you will find most people work for their pocketbooks, not their country.

which is fine but there also needs to be a degree of working together as a nation towards common goals. 

Forget working together as a nation for common goals, I am working for all of humanity to make the world a better place, not just for this nation, but for all the peoples of the world.

8/14/2008 2:58 PM


Elite Pathogen

Elite PathogenElite PathogenElite PathogenElite PathogenElite PathogenElite PathogenElite PathogenElite Pathogen

Last Seen:
Today @ 1:58 PM


Posts: 4,390
Visits: 10,911

I don't agree.  The Russian kind of nationalism of expansion probably would be better off gone but pride in one's country is almost what defines a nation or at least holds it together.  Some of us may be black, some of us may be white, some of us may be mormon, some of us may be Ba'hai, some of us may be repbulicans, some of us may be democrats but if we were healthy, we'd firstly identify ourselves as Americans (or whatever other country you belong to). 

Your statement about wars is very simplistic.  The only way there will ever be total peace on earth is when an iron fisted totalitarian regime rules it all.  Are you willing to trade freedom for peace?  If not, wars are a part of life on this planet and motivation for fighting for freedom is absolutely necessary if we wish to defend it. 

Forget working together as a nation for common goals, I am working for all of humanity to make the world a better place, not just for this nation, but for all the peoples of the world.

Why in the world are these two mutually exclusive? 

I am proud to be an American first and foremost.  I do not pretend that everything we have done in the world has been good (though I think our intentions were at least in the 20th Century) but I do believe this is the best damn country on the earth and if I didn't feel that way, I'd move to the one I thought that was.  What the hell is wrong with that?